Yes, Whataboutism Can Be a Fallacy, But Not Always, and Even Then It Is Usually Quite Rare
February 13, 2021
"Physician, heal thyself."
(Luke 4:23)
"Why do you look at the speck of dust in your brother’s eye,
"Why do you look at the speck of dust in your brother’s eye,
and not notice the log in your own eye?"
(Matt. 7:3)
Yesterday
the term "whataboutism" was trending on social media, because during
the impeachment trial of Former President Donald Trump, Democrats were
anticipating for Trump's lawyers to issue forth a series of
whataboutisms in their response to the accusation that he incited an
insurrection on the Capital Building. At the end of the day, Democrats felt
vindicated, because while Trump's lawyers presented their evidence and pointed out the hypocrisy of
his accusers, they in turn were believed to have also committed the fallacy of whataboutism, which
they thought invalidates all their arguments. But should they feel
vindicated? I would say no, because whataboutisms when you think about
it are very rare, and not as common as accusers would like to think.